Judge denies dismissal of Chattanooga police officer rape case

A municipal liability suit against the City of Chattanooga will move forward after a federal district judge denied the City’s motion to dismiss. The order means that the suit will continue to move forward, bringing the anonymous plaintiff one step closer to obtaining justice.

In May of this year, an anonymous victim–represented by David Randolph Smith & Associates–brought suit against the City of Chattanooga, alleging that she was raped by former Chattanooga police officer Desmond Logan. Plaintiff’s complaint alleged that the City of Chattanooga allowed a “custom of repeated federal rights violations by its officers.”

Plaintiff maintains that the City’s custom of looking the other way and refusing to discipline officers like Logan–who had a history of sexual misconduct–allowed Logan to accomplish his crime.

Plaintiff amended her complaint in June, adding allegations against retired Assistant Chief Edwin McPherson and retired Captain Pedro Bacon. McPherson and Bacon are alleged to have aided in a department cover-up of Logan’s misconduct.

Following Plaintiff’s amendment, the City filed a motion to dismiss her complaint for failure to state a claim. The City argued that a municipal liability claim requires that a “final policymaker” knew of and approved the custom of violations. Plaintiff, however, maintained that the existence of the custom is enough in itself to support a municipal liability claim.

In his December 5th opinion, Judge Harry S. Mattice of the Eastern District of Tennessee concluded: “[I]n the Sixth Circuit, pleading of specific knowledge by specific policymakers is unnecessary to survive a motion to dismiss if the plaintiff claims that a municipal defendant knew or should have known that the actions of its employees were unlawful.” (Internal citations omitted). The judge ultimately denied the City of Chattanooga’s motion to dismiss.

The City also argued that Plaintiff could not rely on newspaper reports when pleading the facts in her complaint. Plaintiff’s first complaint cited numerous newspaper articles detailing Logan’s prior misconduct. The City contended that these articles could not be taken as true for the purposes of stating a claim.

The court disagreed, however, holding that the newspaper reports were to be taken as “exhibits attached to the complaint.” Judge Mattice concluded that the court could “properly consider factual material in [the] complaint that hails from newspaper reporting.”

Following the denial of the City’s motion to dismiss, the case will continue to move forward.

To contact the Tennessee police misconduct lawyers at David Randolph Smith, click here.

Over $500 Million
Recovered Since 1993

We've Helped Thousands of People Just Like You

We are known for getting life-changing results and fighting to make our communities safer.

Why Choose Us As Your  Attorneys?

With us on your side, you can focus on what’s most important – your recovery.

Decades Of Experience

Decades Of Experience

Our Nashville attorneys have over 75 years of combined practice handling cases involving personal injury, medical malpractice, civil rights, medical device lawsuits, wrongful death, and much more.

Excellent Reputation

Excellent Reputation

DRS Law is a well-respected law firm in Nashville and throughout the U.S. Founder, David Randolph Smith, has been selected as a Mid-South Super Lawyer, named one of the Top 100 attorneys in Tennessee in all fields of practice, and is included in the Best Lawyers in America guidebook.

Small Case Volume

Small Case Volume

Unlike many Nashville firms or lawyers that handle a large volume of cases, we concentrate our expertise on a select few cases. With this, our attorneys ensure that every step is taken to obtain the most favorable outcomes for our clients.

We Prepare For Trial

We Prepare For Trial

Every case is meticulously prepared for trial by our trial team and support staff in order to maximize the recovery for our client, whether by settlement or trial verdict. Our proven track record of success has resulted in multi-million-dollar settlements and judgments in a wide variety of individual and group cases.

What to Expect

Our Legal Services Are Completely Personalized To You And Your Unique Needs

01  Free Consultation

Our top-rated Tennessee personal injury lawyers provide free, no-pressure case evaluations. We will help you determine if you have a case and will answer all your questions in plain English. We never charge any fees until we win your case.

02  Personalized Service

If we take your case, it’s because we believe we can help you. We will get to work outlining a strategic plan of action. We want you to feel taken care of during this difficult time — whatever questions you have, we’re here with answers. Frequent check-ins ensure you are comfortable with the progress of your case.

03  You Get Paid

We are passionate about the success of your case and will give it the close attention and focus it deserves. We find solutions that other lawyers miss, discovering key facts that help you win. We call upon our gifts in storytelling to argue your case with passion and conviction so you get the compensation and justice you deserve.

What Our Clients Say